(of a judge, referee etc) to give a judgment or decision (about something)

formally judge

to judge the value, worth, quality of (something)

judge, estimate

to settle a dispute (between two opposite sides, opinions etc) by acting as the chosen judge(s)

achieve settlement

to you say that (a person) is, or has done wrong or that (something) is wrong or unfit for use

blame, convict

to settle (a question or a doubt); give a judgment about (something)

make a determination; settle an issue